Year of the Goat

February 2015, Volume 52 No. 2
Defining “worth”

THE recent announcement that a hoard of some 5,000-plus Anglo-Saxon pennies had been discovered, just before Christmas, by a metal detectorist in Buckinghamshire was treated rather differently by different factions of the press. Inevitably the tabloids and their on-line counterparts initially focussed on the idea of “buried treasure” and how rich the finder was likely soon to be. But the more respectable media outlets spoke about the historical importance of the hoard, explaining how rare the coins from the reigns of Aethelred II (978–1016) and Cnut (1016–35) actually are (especially in the condition that those in the newly-found hoard are), why such hoards were lost/buried in the first place and what happens next in terms of Treasure law, etc.

Unfortunately it wasn’t long before somebody, somewhere, mentioned that such a discovery could be worth over that magic figure—£1 million. On paper, of course, they are right, but there’s always the danger of too much supply and too little demand, so we will have to wait and see what happens with prices if the hoard comes up for sale as separate coins. As we go to press it is too early to know what is going to happen to them. But as soon as that magic figure was mentioned, then all bets were off—there was no more talk of the importance of the coins, no more talk of hoards or their purpose, instead it was all about how much these things were worth. Don’t believe me? Well check the story out on-line, I can pretty much guarantee that if the potential value of the hoard isn’t mentioned in the headline then it will be mentioned in the first line of the copy.

Sadly the same seems to be true of most “coin news” these days (outside of the news we bring you of course). Look at the recent media stories about new issues. The “dateless” 20p (2008), the Kew Gardens 50p (2009), the “drowning swimmer” Olympic 50p (2011)—stories about them all hit the newspapers/ news-sites/TV and each one was accompanied by talk of how much each coin rarity/anomaly was worth. You can pretty much guarantee that the news of the recent 50p incongruity (that the coins in the 2015 sets are denomination-free whereas those for general circulation will proudly declare that they are 50 pences!) will also only be granted space in a newspaper or “airtime” if somebody suggests that there’s money to be made somewhere along the line.

As a keen numismatist I’m not sure how I feel about this. I am not sure how I feel when the one question on everyone’s lips when talking about coins seems to be “what’s it worth?”. Of course, the value of a coin is hugely important—we wouldn’t produce the COIN YEARBOOK if it wasn’t—but we like to think that people buying such price-guides are doing so because they have an interest beyond simply how much profit they can make. Then again isn’t it good that people are talking about coins at all? In this day and age where the traditional hobbies and pastimes we all grew up with are being pushed aside by the ubiquitous screens clutched by all and sundry, and where there is so much news circulating all around us that information overload is a very real problem, it has to be a good thing to get a look-in at all. And yes, I know that “£1 million hoard found” is probably a far more appealing headline than “Historically important hoard found”, but I wish it wasn’t and I wish that occasionally the journalists and newsreaders would see beyond the price of things and look at their real value. At least we all know what the true value is, and it is that that keeps us collecting.

Order Back Issue

You can order this item as a back issue, simply select a delivery option from the list below and add it to your shopping basket. The price displayed is the cost of the magazine and the delivery combined.

Free Trial Issue
Click Here
Year of the Goat
Free trial issue Subscribe Buy this back issue

In This Issue

The hero of Roman architecture
A numismatic mystery
18th century Manx silver examined
Feature article46
Year of the wood goat
Indulging in some numismatic lunarcy
Changing times
Post-WWI Austria-Hungary and its coins
Bon voyage!
Holiday essentials for the numismatist
Medallic miscellany57
Paris 1968 - Were you there?
Student protest remembered
Collector’s notebook61
Of clowns and coins
Some thoughts on our current coinage
Back to basics67
Numerical grading
Pondering story of the 1-70 Sheldon scale
From small beginnings
Collecting Scottish tokens
Banknote feature75
Assignats of the French Revolution
Currency during chaos
Confessions of a paper money obsessive
Training issues for a monetary change


From the Editorial Desk2
Coin News & Views14
View of the Bay22
Around the World24
New Issues Coin Update26
Royal Mint Bulletin28
Market Scene31
From the Archives62
Price Guide to Decimal £564
Coin of the Month66
Banknote News71
New Issues Banknote Update72
Dealer Directory85
Diary Dates88
Semi-display Adverts90
The Web Page92
Classified Advertising95